This website uses cookies
Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

File / Download
The build vs. buy decision is back on the table. AI made building faster and cheaper. It made vendor products more complex and more expensive simultaneously. It created identity problems nobody has fully solved yet. This guide gives you a framework to make the right call — whether you're the practitioner buying a platform, the vendor competing in a changed market, or the consultant trying to give honest advice without a conflict of interest.
Most practitioners treat build vs. buy as a values question. Build shops build. Buy shops buy. Neither side has a framework that accounts for what AI actually changed about the decision in 2025 and 2026.
This guide does.
Written from three seats at the table — the buyer, the vendor, and the partner — it gives you the analytical tools to make the right call for your specific situation, not the one your sales rep or your consulting firm wants you to make.
What's inside:
The Identity Capability Map — a three-zone framework that tells you what you should always buy, what you should configure on top of a platform, and the narrow set of things worth building from scratch. Most programs are fighting battles in the wrong zone.
The 2026 Decision Matrix — five scored variables that produce a defensible recommendation based on your program's actual maturity, talent, integration complexity, regulatory exposure, and timeline. Not a gut call. A number with reasoning behind it.
The TCO Reality Check — the hidden costs that never appear in a vendor proposal. Integration tax, customization debt, FTE overhead, switching costs at year five. Run these before you sign anything.
The Vendor Evaluation Scorecard — seven weighted criteria for evaluating identity vendors in the AI era, with scoring guidance that reflects what actually matters now versus what vendor marketing tells you matters.
The Five Diagnostic Questions — for partners and consultants who need to give honest advice without the conflict of interest that comes with implementation revenue on the line.
Plus: a Build vs. Buy Assessment Framework that structures the full engagement from discovery through recommendation, and a direct take on the three remaining defensible moats in identity vendor competition.
This is not a survey of the market. It is not a vendor comparison. It is a practitioner's framework for making one of the most consequential infrastructure decisions in identity security, with the AI context that changes the calculus baked in.
Format: PDF, 25 pages Audience: IAM practitioners, identity program leaders, security consultants, and identity vendors Included with: Knight and Master tier subscriptions